Thursday, February 27, 2014

Earthworks and Cows and Hills, Oh My! A View of Chillicothe in the 1830s

"Chillicothe with Cows" Staffordshire platter. Used courtesy of Prices 4 Antiques.

In the early through mid 19th century, a considerable volume of Staffordshire pottery was created with views of American scenes. They were created, in Staffordshire, for the United States audience. Four illustrate Ohio views: two of Chillicothe, the first capitol of the state; and one each of Sandusky and Columbus.

Sandusky Staffordshire platter. Reproduced from Pictures of early New York on dark blue Staffordshire pottery, together with pictures of Boston and New England, Philadelphia, the South and West (1899) by R.T. Haines Halsey. Used courtesy of Boston Public Library and the Internet Archive.

There's little doubt that the Sandusky platter does, in fact, illustrate Sandusky, Ohio. It's consistent enough what was known about the city at the time that we can be confident in this assumption.

Columbus Staffordshire platter. Reproduced from Pictures of early New York on dark blue Staffordshire pottery, together with pictures of Boston and New England, Philadelphia, the South and West (1899) by R.T. Haines Halsey. Used courtesy of Boston Public Library and the Internet Archive.

Likewise, we can say the same for this view of Columbus. It illustrates the city from a viewpoint similar to that used by Thomas Kelah Wharton, below.

Columbus, Ohio from the south west
Columbus, Ohio from the south west. A drawing (1832) by Thomas Kelah Wharton. Used courtesy of the New York Public Library.

The similar in the lay of the city in Wharton's viewpoint, from the southwest, would seem to suggest that both views were made near the same time.

The two Chillicothe views - the one illustrated above and Chillicothe with raft - have, to this point, presented more difficulty. The most obvious landmark, the first statehouse, isn't visible in either view. It's been suggested by many that these views might not be Chillicothe at all, but rather, some other images chosent to stand in.

I tend to be cautious about asserting that a view isn't a place without evidence as to the actual location of the view being depicted. For an example of the dangers of these assumptions, I need point no further than Karl Bodmer's print of the Cleveland lighthouse, which many asserted couldn't be Cleveland because the lighthouse was clearly different and had different surroundings. It turned out that the structure being depicted was the harbor light, as is illustrated in depth in New Find! First* Painting of Cleveland in Color!

S.W. View of Chillicothe
S.W. View of Chillicothe. An engraving (1839) by Charles Foster. Reproduced from Chillicothe, Ohio by G. Richard Peck. Used courtesy of the Ross County Historical Society.

The landscape illustrated in the Staffordshire platter of Chillicothe seemed inconsistent with the one shown in this 1839 engraving by Charles Foster, one of four views of the city that he printed that year. This made me less comfortable with the assumption that the view on the platter was, in fact, Chillicothe, Ohio.

George Wood residence, Chillicothe, Ohio
George Wood residence, Chillicothe, Ohio. A watercolor painting (late 1830s). Used courtesy of Donald Carpentier.

A couple weeks ago, my colleague, Andrew Richmond, asked me if I might be able to identify the house illustrated in this watercolor from the late 1830s, the residence of one George Wood. I dug in. While Wood was clearly a man of considerable means, I wasn't able to learn that much about him. I was able to narrow down the general location of the residence, but beyond that, I was unsure. What followed was a lot of hemming and hawing.

Finally, I sent an email to Pat Medert, Archivist, at the Ross County Historical Society. Her response was most illuminating: "The house in the painting appears to be that of George Wood who resided at 144 W. Fifth St. George was born in 1793 in Jefferson County, VA. The family moved to Kentucky when he was a child, and in 1810, he and his brother, John moved to Chillicothe. They were partners in the mercantile and pork packing businesses. George also invested extensively in farm land in Ross County and was a person of considerable wealth at the time of his death in January 1861. He was never married and his estate went to his sister, Susan Hoffman."

Medert added, "George bought the property in 1833 and erected the house in 1837. It can be seen in a sketch made by Charles Foster in 1839. The house was remodeled in 1874, and renovations included the construction of an addition to the east side of the house. It is still standing and is well maintained."

(The George Wood residence is about a third of the way from the left in the Charles Foster print.)

The George Wood residence is on the south side of the street. The surrounding geology means that this view is looking approximately southwest.

This is, indeed, an interesting painting, but what does it have to do with the Staffordshire Chillicothe (with cows)?

Look at the background of the George Wood residence. The hills aren't covered with trees like they are in the Charles Foster print. Further, they're similar in style to the view on Chillicothe (with cows). This suggested to me, "Hey, this might actually be Chillicothe, Ohio."

With the assumption that the view on this piece of Staffordshire was Chillicothe, I tested what would happen if one made the rest of the evidence fit that hypothesis.

Chillicothe Courthouse, Etc., in 1801
Chillicothe Courthouse, Etc., in 1801. A print (June, 1842) by Horace C. Grosvenor. Published in American Pioneer (June, 1842). Used courtesy of the Ohio Historical Society.

This is the first statehouse, as illustrated in 1842. At the time, the building was still standing - this represents a reasonably accurate depiction of the structure. The statehouse was in the middle of this city. What this illustration doesn't convey are the significant quantity of buildings that were built up around the structure by the 1830s.

Since the statehouse was only two stories tall, it wouldn't stand out much among the buildings.

Detail, Chillicothe with cows Platter
Chillicothe with cows (detail). A Staffordshire platter (circa 1830). Used courtesy of Dennis and Dad Antiques.

With the assumption that this is Chillicothe, the statehouse is most likely represented by the cupola indicated by the green arrow. With that knowledge, how can we orient ourselves in this city?

The 1860 Topographical map of Ross County, Ohio includes the first detailed map of Chillicothe that I've been able to find. Note: if you're aware of an earlier one, please let me know. The lack of such a map seems odd, especially given that one of the great early maps of the state, Hough and Bourne's 1815 Map of the State of Ohio was published there.

The 1860 map doesn't help much. The landscape illustrated in the foreground, which I assumed was the floodplain of the Scioto River, had been significantly changed since the view used for the Staffordshire platter was made.

Map of a Section of Twelve Miles of the Scioto Valley with its Ancient Monuments
Map of a Section of Twelve Miles of the Scioto Valley with its Ancient Monuments. Constructed by E.G. Squier, 1847. A print (June, 1847) by Sarony and Major. Plate II in Ancient Monuments of the Mississippi Valley (June, 1847) by Ephraim G. Squier and Edwin H. Davis. Used courtesy of the Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library, Yale University.

In a desperate measure for any sort of early map of the city at all, I remembered this wonderful view from Squier and Davis' 1847 Ancient Monuments of the Mississippi Valley. It illustrates all of the Native American earthworks present in the vicinity of Chillicothe, most of which are now lost.

Detail, Map of a Section of Twelve Miles of the Scioto Valley with its Ancient Monuments
Detail, Map of a Section of Twelve Miles of the Scioto Valley with its Ancient Monuments. Constructed by E.G. Squier, 1847. A print (June, 1847) by Sarony and Major. Plate II in Ancient Monuments of the Mississippi Valley (June, 1847) by Ephraim G. Squier and Edwin H. Davis. Used courtesy of the Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library, Yale University.

This detail illustrates the area being illustrated. In the lower left are the hills we see in the background. The green "X" marks the approximate location of the statehouse. The artist's viewpoint is marked by a red arrow.

The cows, then, it seems, are sitting inside a circular mound! What better visual icon could there be for that area, really, than the earthworks built by the Native Americans?

Not only does this information help to reasonably conclude that the view is, indeed, Chillicothe, Ohio, but it means that we now have an image of a Native American earthwork that before this point we knew only by a measured drawing!


  1. Surely this needs to go to Ohio History!

    D. Anderson

  2. Dag, you're a good detective!

  3. Remember, greater Chillicothe is cradled by two "hills". The biggest, which is bigger than a hill but small than a mountain to the northeast east and across the Scioto is part of Great Seal Park. The other, almost immediate to the west southwest of downtown was the location of the Dard Hunter residence. My feeling is that the view of the plate is looking southwest toward town, with Great Seal behind, towards the west hill and plateau. That would put the house and State Capital in the right place. By the way, the Chillicothe Gazette offices are located on the old state capital location and are a reproduction of that building.

  4. There are a bolster focuses to be investigated up to biting bike credits. Some overtop advancement is uncovered from the borrower if a true blue change is to be made. The borrower disservice to neighborhood complete on a best in a huge part of what warm of bike he needs to purchase, what cast and perform and so forth.

  5. You oblige a credit in a burst, yet are so unassuming it would be colossal ask relatives or accomplices, and are frightened of the examination material joined into a bank advance. Shed every one of your strains, for help is a mouse click away at the present time car title loans

  6. Condemned is forearmed! So it is with payday credits. On the off chance that you get a handle on what this sort of credit will cost you, you will be in a transcendent position than measure the inclinations and insufficiencies of settling on it. In this way you will correspondingly know definitively what total you have to pay back to the payday advance affiliation

  7. These records are achievable in the secured moreover in the isolated structure. Along these lines, you see the settlement to gathering the cash through any of these choices. Moored sorts of records sponsorship for an aegis in acceptance of cash. Cash Advance

  8. cần làm websitelà các thông tin cơ sở dữ liệu được chủ website thêm vào khi tải dữ liệu lên host Thiết kế website phòng khám nha khoaVới việc thiết kế các thông tin trên website của bạn hướng tới lợi ích của khách hàng điều đó giúp khách hàng sẽ dễ dàng khai thác các thông tin trên website của Bạn Thiết kế website spaVà một khi khách hàng hài lòng thì Bạn đã tạo dựng được một hình ảnh tốt đẹp về mình trong tâm trí và tình cảm của khách hàng, giúp công ty, doanh nghiệp bạn trở lên chuyên nghiệp hơn. Thiết kế website tìm việcvới một nền công nghệ thông tin phát triển như ngày nay, Bạn hoàn toàn có thể tin tưởng rằng việc thiết kế website thiết kế Website quán cafesẽ là một phương tiện truyền thông tốt nhất để Bạn có thể thực hiện ý tưởng của mình trong việc quảng bá web và tiếp thị của mình một cách sinh động và hiệu quả nhất. Thiết kế website giải tríChi phí để thiết kế website chuyên nghiệp thật là quá nhỏ bé so với những núi chi phí mà bạn bỏ ra để quảng bá các hoạt động của Bạn bằng các phương tiện truyền thống. Thiết Kế Website Nhà Hàng Tiệc CướiVới hàng ngàn người lượt truy cập Internet thường xuyên, công ty, doanh nghiệp bạn sẽ nhanh chóng được biết đến, khách hàng có thể truy cập thông tin về doanh nghiệp Thiết Kế Website Bán Vé Máy Bay Onlinecông ty hoặc tổ chức của bạn trên website vào bất cứ lúc nào và từ bất cứ nơi đâu, chỉ với một chiếc máy tính kết nối vào internet. Nó quảng bá ở thị trường toàn cầu, toàn thế giới (việc mà báo chí không làm được điều này) Thiết Kế Website Trang Trí Nội ThấtVới một môi trường internet năng động, bùng nổ, linh hoạt, Bạn dễ dàng thay đổi và cập nhật các thông tin lên website của mình để làm thoả mãn yêu cầu của mọi khách hàng kể cả các khách hàng khó tính nhất. nâng cấp websiteBạn đang cần thiết kế website nhằm quảng bá cho doanh nghiệp, công ty hoặc cá nhân mình. cong ty thiet ke webHTSolution là một công ty thiết kế website chuyên nghiệp cà chất lượng nhất, chúng tôi luôn đem đến cho các bạn những sản phẩm chất lượng và uy tiến hàng đầu

  9. In the event that you incline toward a joint of activity session, and never like the thought of picking up an occupied get prepared or on the other hand transport, well then for brief excursions a bicycle would be a genial inclination, through Barclays Never-consummation circle select. cash advance

  10. phim ngọa hổ tàng long 2Cô chia sẻ: “Ban đầu tôi vốn tham gia casting một vai khác hồi đầu năm 2014 phim phượng tù hoàng 2015phim chuyển thể từ tác phẩm tiêu thuyết ngôn tình xuyên không cùng tên của tác giả Thiên Y Hữu Phong phim cương thi tvbnổi tiếng qua series đình đám Khử tà diệt ma. Còn với TVB, Cương (Blue Veins) là bộ phim đầu tiên có nhân vật chính phim Naruto Shippuuden tron bo Người đứng đầu ngôi làng, Hokage đệ Tứ, đã hi sinh chính bản thân mình để phong ấn Cửu Vĩ vào cơ thể một đứa bé sơ sinh tên là Uzumaki Naruto. phim hạnh phúc muộn màng hứa hẹn sẽ là một kiệt tác điện ảnh nữa của Ấn Độ sẽ lên sóng THVL1. cô dâu 8 tuổi phần 5 Today TV vtc7 phim co dau 8 tuoi 1250 tập cuối phần 6 trọn bộ sẽ làm cho cuộc đời Anandi xem hậu duệ của mặt trờiKim Eun-sook được biết đến là nữ biên kịch của các bộ phim truyền hình nổi tiếng do đài SBS sản xuất như “파리의 연인” (Chuyện tình Pa-ri) sản xuất năm 2004 phim hd onlinephim hd online miễn phí chất lượng cao tại, liên tục cập nhật các phim hd chất lượng cao mới nhất nhanh nhất. xem phim tha thi thien habước chân vào giang hồ để tìm hiểu cuộc sống bá tính như thế nào và che đi thân phận công chúa
    hạt điều rang muối có tác dụng gìCòn các hạt điều nhập khẩu không có được vị ngon như vậy. hạt điều rang muối bình phướcKhoáng chất đồng có trong hạt điều cung cấp sự linh hoạt cho xương, khớp và mạch máu. mua hạt điều rang muối bình phướcChỉ sử dụng hạt điều Bùi Đăng-Bình Phước-Việt Nam, không dùng hạt điều nhập khẩu

  11. As per TransUnion reports, automobile advances top spending plan need installment records. Indeed, even the accident of the lodging business sector, homes advances still fall second to auto installments. The home loan wrongdoing rates push past 30 days yet this cost still assumes need over acknowledgment card obligation. Cash Advance

  12. When you are ascertaining the moderate regularly scheduled installments for an auto advance, there are various variables that come into thought. One of them is rate of hobby. It continues changing from spot to put and relying on the record of loan repayment of the client and general money related condition. Payday Loans


  14. Students are the asset of any nation. Apprentice loans are accessible for acceptance who can not allow their education. Cash Advance

  15. Thousands and millions of bodies today are demography advice from Tax Acquittance Banknote Beforehand and there are several lenders that you can calmly acquisition online and offline both. Consistently allocution about the absorption rates, backward acquittal penalties, and any added questions that you accept in apperception afore signing up for anything; afterwards all, money cannot be taken after accepting a accurate reason.
    Payday Loans Costa-mesa

  16. Detractors of the industry like to use APR (annual allotment rate) to call why payday loans are expensive. An APR is the amount of borrowing money as if it were based on a 1 year loan. Payday loans are not one year loans; they are usually anywhere amid 10 day and 30 day loans or up until your abutting payday.
    payday loans chicago

  17. The acknowledgment could be an online payday loan, and while the APR (annual allotment rate) for such loans is high, you alone accept it for beneath than a ages afterwards which it is paid in abounding in a distinct payment. Because it is a appropriate blazon of loan, there are specialist companies that action them, and additionally abounding cowboys that will booty advantage of your allegation if you are not careful.
    Payday Loans

  18. So what are the pitfalls of such loans? Not abounding if you accumulate to the agreement, although it is that which could be your downfall. If you abort to accord a payday accommodation again the penalties can be severe. To accept them you accept to accept the antecedent charges. The fee for such a accommodation could be as abundant as $100 on a $400 loan, which agency that if you pay it in a month, the APR is 300%.
    Cash Advance Chicago